Friday, May 7, 2010

Bows and Arrows in the American Revolution?

Imagine a line of redcoated British soldiers marching across the battlefield at Camden. Just as the American army begins to break and run, a crack unit of 500 colonial soldiers armed with longbows dashes onto the field and rains down arrow barrage after arrow barrage on the British soldiers commanded by General Lord Charles Cornwallis.

Would this have made a difference? Given Horatio Gates' incompetence and/or cowardice (take your pick), perhaps not. But it sure would've made things interesting! And it probably would've disrupted the British advance enough to allow more Americans to escape the field.

No one can know for certain, but such "what if" scenarios are fun to contemplate. And, in this case, the scenario really isn't that far-fetched. The use of bows and arrows is something that Benjamin Franklin endorsed.

For more on this possibility, check out an article just published over at "The American Revolution & Founding Era" blog. You can click on the following link to check it out...

"Guns and Bows and Arrows"

7 comments:

Coach Bennett said...

I think that this is an interesting argument, but one that was not remotely likely. The Continental Army was poorly supplied throughout the war. We were not a manufacturing country, to suggest using bows and arrows showed how far Franklin was from understanding the real problems that the Army faced. They could not get enough weapons, food, clothing, etc. Why would they introduce bows and arrows, where would these have been produced, not to mention you would have to have taught all of them the proper way to shoot. Whereas, almost all men of the army and the militia could handle a gun, but a bow and arrow? Would you have stayed on the field and fired an arrow into the most powerful army in the world, who was bearing down on you with muskets and Ferg. rifles.. No way, you would have ran faster than the continentials normally did when forming against the Redcoats (well in at least New York).

spikedpsycho said...

The last time bows were seriously used in warfare was during the English Civil War in the 1600s. 130 years before the American War of Independence. The longbow had been the weapon of choice for English armies up until the early 16th century, and laws had been passed to force English commoners to give up other sports in favour of archery. Even Henry VIII did longbow practice and competitions among his other sporting interests.

But even the English, whose longbowmen had won them so many notable victories, gave them up over the course of the 16th century in favour of the matchlock and pike. As other answers have said it took a long time to train a competent battlefield archer that took months or years, training someone to shoot a gun...weeks.

And overall they worked out cheaper. The wood and labour needed for a good heavy warbow and for the hundreds of arrows the archer was expected to rain on the enemy was not cheap, and over the course of the 16th century gun manufacture improved immensely. By the late 18th century flintlocks and ball would have been way cheaper and faster to produce.

Anonymous said...

FOR RECOVERY LOST FUNDS FROM SCAMMER / CRYPTOCURRENCY, RECOVERY OF STOLEN BITCOIN, Please everyone should be careful and stop being deceived by all these brokers and account managers, they scammed me over $50,000 of my investment capital, they kept on requesting for extra funds before a withdrawal request can be accepted and processed, in the end, I lost all my money. All efforts to reach out to their customer support desk had declined, I found it very hard to move on. God so kind I followed a broadcast that teaches on how scammed victims can recover their fund, I contacted the email provided for consultation, I got feedback after some hours and I was asked to provide all legal details concerning my investment, I did exactly what they instructed me to do without delay, to my greatest surprise I was able to recover my money back including my profit which my capital generated. I said I will not hold this to myself but share it to the public so that all scammed victims can get their funds back. Email Address: Email: (wizardcharles1@gmail.com)

Removing Bad Records from Both Public and Private database

Do you want to Increase your Credit score and top up your credit balance?

Visit website : https://wizardcharlesgrouphackers.com/.n/

yanmaneee said...

jordan shoes
kobe shoes
bape
supreme
giannis antetokounmpo shoes
jordan shoes
yeezy supply
a bathing ape
jordan 11
supreme clothing

Unknown said...

DO YOU NEED A PERSONAL/BUSINESS/INVESTMENT LOAN? CONTACT US TODAY VIA WhatsApp +19292227023 Email drbenjaminfinance@gmail.com

HELLO
Loan Offer Alert For Everyone! Are you financially down and you need an urgent credit/financial assistance? Or are you in need of a loan to start-up/increase your business or buy your dream house. GET YOUR INSTANT LOAN APPROVAL 100% GUARANTEED TODAY NO MATTER YOUR CREDIT SCORE. WhatsApp:+19292227023 Email: drbenjaminfinance@gmail.com

EloisaSteuber said...

What’s Happening i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely useful and it has helped me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its aided me. Good job. national archives civil war records

haphet said...

t6s40n6w05 c3h37r1b36 v0d72k1q84 i6t82w3u63 v9j88n6o50 v7i71u0a66